In the novel To Kill a
Mockingbird and the motion picture called The Help many people are
subjects to racism and poverty. Atticus Finch once said “you never really
understand a person until you consider things from his point of view.” Few
characters in both the novel and movie take this quote into play, many others
too scared of the change that it might bring. Courage, a major lesson in each
piece of literature was something that many people each period of time. While
the two both have many more things in common they’re also many comparisons in
the way that both are taught.
In the novel To Kill a Mocking bird a young girl named Scout tells the story of
an African American man who was accused of rape and put on trial in Maycomb,
Alabama in the 1930’s. The Help was
told through the perspective of a young adult living in Jackson, Mississippi in
the 1960’s. Skeeter seeks to tell the story of African American maids in book
that she’s writing. In ways Scout and Skeeter have many things a like; they’re
both strong willed and determined girls who don’t reduce themselves to the
sexism of both eras. They both have strong feelings for equality of the races
and have both have strong bonds with the maids that raised them. Characters in The Help could also be seen or compared
to those in To Kill a Mockingbird,
for instance Arthur Radley also known as Boo Radley was a reclusive man who did
little things to show Scout and her brother Jem that the rumors about him being
a bad person weren’t true. Boo could compare with Celia Foote who was labeled
false accusations of Jackson’s ladies who labeled as a cheat. Celia tried to do
things to be friendly to Hilly and Elizabeth but they refused her kindness. The
settings of both the stories take part in their similarities. Both stories take
place in the south where worlds like “colored” and “negro” are used often in
the segregated America.
While they’re many aspects that
they both have in common there are also things that differ in both the novel
and movie. In To Kill a Mockingbird the
tone could be serious and dreary on the topic of racism and Tom Robinson. While
The Help had serious moments it could
also be humorous and lively at times even when the subject at hand was just as
serious. The Help goes through the
motions of showing everyone’s perspective as well. Ablileen, Minny, and other
maids got to share their stories in however the Finch’s maid Calpurnia rarely
shares many of her opinions in the novel. This is another way of showing the
diversity in each story. The biggest thing that sets the two apart is the
story line for them both. To Kill a
Mockingbird tells the story of black man named Tom Robinson who is accused
of raping a white woman. Tom is put to trial and is defended by Atticus Finch where
he is convicted in an unjust law system. It also tells stories of Scout, Jem,
Dill and the troubles that they all get into. The Help is about a young girl called Skeeter, fresh out of college
seeking a career in journalism. She decides to interview black maids in which
they all share their encounters working for white families.
In conclusion
both the novel and the movie have a meaning much more significant. Within both
fictional works of art the lesson being taught is much more extraordinary. Skin
color is not defining neither is gender or the amount of money you have, equality
of all is much more important. If you reflect on the courage that Atticus had
to defend an African American man. The courage of Skeeter, Ablileen, and the
several other maids to not only be women to but to see both races as equal.
That’s what they both sought out to teach. When believe in the right thing don’t
be afraid to be heard and to make a change especially when it could have a
powerful impact on other people’s lives as well.
Nice essay, I really liked how you said that Calpurnia doesn't relate to the maids from The Help, she just does what she has to do. I didn't see anything that needed to be corrected :0
ReplyDeletehi (:
ReplyDeleteI think that your essay is amazing. I love how great your grammar is throughout the entire essay and I like how you hit all of the major points between both the novel and the movie. One thing that you might need to work on is the use of commas in the first few paragraphs, but overall your essay was wonderful.
ReplyDeleteHI
ReplyDeleteMakiyah, your essay was great and I really enjoyed it. You made great comparisons through out you're entire essay. The only thing to work on is in your essay you left out some words. I do it all the time so don't feel bad. Just make sure go back and proof read afterward and you will be fine. I loved your conclusion a lot! Great way to end your essay.
ReplyDeleteWonderful job! Your use of vocabulary and amount of detail made the essay easy to follow and understand. I was worried at first that you were not tying everything to your thesis, but your conclusion did a terrific job of bringing all your thoughts together. Grade: 95/100
ReplyDelete